Chef Paul Catering & Bakery serves the suburbs of Milwaukee & Chicago scrumptious, affordable wedding cakes, specialty cakes, pastries & desserts for catered events since 1984.
No event is too large or too small for Chef Paul's in-house bakery. Whether planning an intimate dinner party, black-tie gala corporate gathering or wedding reception our team works closely with you to design delicious, customizable desserts.
Chef Paul Bakery Menu
Use the menu buttons below to review several of our in-house "Bakery Menus"
All New Bakery Selections
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookies
Giant chocolate chip cookie decorated with buttercream icing as desired
Cup Cakes
Yummy cupcakes & mini cupcakes in any of our standard cake flavors
decorated with buttercream icing as desired
Photo Cookies
Shortbread cookies frosted with our delicious buttercream frosting topped with your photo and/or message.
Great for birthdays, showers, client gifts (with company logo), & personalized place cards
Breads & Rolls
Brown Bread
Loaf of freshly baked brown bread
Butter Croissants
Cocktail Rolls
Traditional white cocktail rolls baked
from scratch in house
Cocktail Rolls-Presliced
Traditional white cocktail rolls baked from scratch
in house and pre-sliced for sandwiches
Cornbread Muffins
Super moist corn bread muffins
Crusty Rolls for Italian Beef
Crusty white rolls pre-sliced and perfect for
serving with Italian Beef
Focaccia Rolls
Focaccia rolls topped with garlic parmesan,
tomato herb, or black olive topping
French Bread
Crusty 10 inch French loaf.
Must be heated before serving
Garlic Rolls
Cheesy garlic rolls baked from scratch in house
Hawaiian Bread
Sweet & savory Hawaiian bread loaf
Italian Bread
Crusty Italian white bread loaves
Pineapple Bread
Loaf of Chef Paul's signature recipe of pineapple bread. Best served with chunky chicken salad
Rye Rolls
Baked in house traditional light rye rolls
Sundried Tomato Mozzarella
& Basil Rolls
Freshly baked white rolls with pieces of sun-dried tomato, mozzarella cheese, & basil baked inside
Wheat Cocktail Rolls
Traditional whole wheat cocktail rolls
Muffins & Breakfast Pastries
Full Size Muffins
Full size fresh baked savory and/or sweet muffins
Variety of flavor choices
Mini Muffins
Mini fresh baked savory and/or sweet muffins
Variety of flavor choices
Orange Muffins
Mildly sweet orange muffins infused with
sundried black cherries
Scones
Freshly baked heart shaped scones
with dried cherries
Mini Sweet Rolls
Decadent fruit filled mini sweet rolls drizzled
with vanilla frosting
German Apple Strudel
Apple & cinnamon filling in a flaky, buttery,
pastry crust. Serves 10-16
Cherry Cream Cheese Strudel
Cherry & vanilla cream cheese filling in a
flaky puff pastry crust
Dutch Apple Bars
Half sheet of flaky pie crust topped with cinnamon and sugar apples, streusel topping, & drizzled
with white chocolate
9 Inch Pie Flavors
Dutch Apple
Cherry Struesel
Blueberry Struesel
Pumpkin Spice
Pecan
Chocolate Pecan
Chocolate Silk
Lemon Cream
Key Lime
Mincemeat
Frozen Grasshopper
Frozen or Strawberry Margarita
With pretzel crust
Cheesecake Flavors
Vanilla
Vanilla
With fresh strawberries
Vanilla
With cherries
Chocolate Chip
Banana Chocolate Chip
Cherry Chocolate Chip
White Chocolate
Coconut
Banana
Mocha
Bailey’s
Eggnog
Lemon Chiffon
Dreamsicle
Key Lime
Layered Lemon Meringue
Pumpkin Pie
Pumpkin Vanilla
Carrot Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Neapolitan
Turtle
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Raspberry
Specialty Cake Flavors
Pina Colada Cake
A tropical combination of moist pineapple cake layered with rich cream cheese icing & covered
with shredded coconut
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Three layers of homemade chocolate cake filled & frosted with lots of creamy chocolate mousse. The cake is then garnished with whipped cream & covered white & dark chocolate dipped strawberries. It’s then drizzled with white & dark chocolate for the ultimate chocolate treat
White Chocolate Mousse Cake
This cake is similar to the Chocolate Mousse cake except it is filled & frosted with White Chocolate Mousse. It is also covered with chocolate dipped strawberries then drizzled with chocolate
German Chocolate Cake
An old fashioned favorite. Our version is made from scratch with lots of nuts & coconut. The cake is a three layer homemade chocolate cake filled with a fudgy buttercream & topped with a generous
layer of German chocolate topping
Black Forest Cake
Rich chocolate cake layered with cherries & frosted
real whipped cream & shaved chocolate
Flourless Chocolate Cake
with Raspberry Sauce
A decadent chocolate cake with a velvety texture.
Topped with chocolate ganache and served
with sweet raspberry sauce on the side
Tiramisu Layer Cake
Chocolate ladyfingers dipped in espresso & liquor layered between traditional tiramisu filling. Chocolate ladyfingers dress the sides of the cake & shaved chocolate is drizzled on top
Triple Chocolate Cake
Our chocolateest chocolate cake! Rich chocolate cake layered & frosted with chocolate raspberry
buttercream then drizzled with
melted dark chocolate
Red Velvet Cake
Traditional red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting
Rainbow Cake
Great fun for a child's birthday
A layer of vanilla flavored orange, green, & purple cake layered with buttercream in yellow & blue then
frosted in red. A rainbow in each slice
Grandma’s Cinnamon Bundt Cake
Our all time best seller
A delicious vanilla bundt cake with a stripe of cinnamon & brown sugar in the middle with
a nutty cinnamon top
Boston Cream Cake
Yellow cake layered with custard then topped
with chocolate glaze
Orange Toffee Almond Torte
6 layers of yellow cake filled & frosted with a wonderfully sweet toffee orange buttercream
Strawberry Whip Cream Cake
White cake filled with fresh strawberry filling, frosted with whipped cream frosting, & topped with whole
fresh strawberries
Basket of Flowers Cake
A cake in chocolate, yellow, or marble with your choice of filling. This cake is beautifully decorated with buttercream chocolate or white in a basketweave design & filled to the brim with buttercream roses in your desired color. It looks like a basket of flowers & is a great
centerpiece for your next shower or tea
Three Milk Cake
Pastel de Tres Leches
Vanilla cake soaked with a three milk mixture filled with fresh strawberries & frosted with real whipped cream frosting. Extra three milk mixture is included on
the side to pour over the cake when serving
Lady Ann’s Torte
Vanilla cake filled with custard & strawberries. Frosted with whip cream frosting with lady fingers to decorate the sides & whip cream on top. This can be made with chocolate cake instead if desired
Mini Pastries
Banana Cream Tarts
Sugar cookie shell filled with custard, sliced bananas,
& garnished with whipped cream
Banana Macadamia Nut Tarts
Made from scratch sugar cookie shell filled with vanilla mousse then topped with sliced bananas, whipped cream, & toasted macadamia nuts
Blueberry Tarts
Sugar cookie shell filled with blueberry filling
& topped with whipped cream
Cherry Tarts
Tart cherries in a sugar cookie shell
topped with whip cream
Chocolate Dipped Kiwi
Kiwi slices dipped in white chocolate
& drizzled with dark chocolate
Chocolate Dipped Oranges
Orange wedges dipped in dark chocolate
& drizzled with white chocolate
Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Strawberries dipped in dark chocolate &
drizzled with white chocolate
Chocolate Mousse Tarts
Decadent bittersweet chocolate mousse in a
sugar cookie shell topped with whip cream
& drizzled with dark chocolate
Chocolate Petit Fours
Flourless chocolate cake squares coated
with chocolate ganache &
seasonally decorated
Coconut Cream Tarts
Coconut cream in a sugar cookie shell topped
with whip cream & toasted coconut
Dutch Apple Tarts
Baked apples & cinnamon in a sugar cookie shell topped with struesel topping & drizzled
with white chocolate
Fresh Strawberry Tarts
Sugar cookie shell with vanilla bean mousse, fresh strawberry, whip cream garnish, &
bittersweet chocolate drizzle
Key Lime Mousse Tarts
The perfect combination of sweet & tart
lime mousse in a sugar cookie shell
Kiwi Tarts
Sugar cookie shell filled with vanilla bean mousse
topped with fresh sliced kiwi &
drizzled white chocolate
Lemon Bar Squares
Baked from scratch, sweet & tart
lemon bar squares
Lemon Mousse Tarts
The perfect combination of sweet & tart lemon
mousse in a sugar cookie shell
Mandarin Orange Tarts
Sugar cookie shell with lemon mousse, sliced
mandarin oranges & whip cream garnish
Mini Cheesecake Squares
Mini New York style cheesecake squares
with graham cracker crust
Mini Cherry Cheesecakes
Petit New York style cheesecakes bites in a sugar
cookie crust garnished with a touch of
sour cream & a cherry
Mini Chocolate Eclairs
Made from scratch eclair shells filled with Bavarian
cream & topped with semisweet chocolate
Mini Cream Cheese Brownies
Mini fudge chip brownies with chocolate cream
cheese frosting & dark chocolate drizzle
Mini Cream Puff Swans
Mini puff shells filled with whip cream in the shape
of a swan dusted with powdered sugar
Mini Cream Puffs
Made from scratch pastry shells filled with whip
cream & topped with white chocolate
Mini Pumpkin Bar Bites
Bite size squares of our famous pumpkin cake
with cream cheese icing
Peanut Butter Tarts
Sugar cookie shell filled with peanut butter mousse,
topped with whip cream & chopped nuts
Pina Colada Cake Bites
Moist pineapple cake bites topped with
cream cheese icing &
shredded coconut
Raspberry Mousse Tarts
Mousse made with fresh raspberries in a sugar
cookie shell topped with whip cream
& toasted almonds
Tuxedo Style Dipped Strawberries
Dark chocolate dipped strawberries wearing a white chocolate shirt with dark chocolate
buttons & bow tie
Please give us a call or text us at 847-623-8750. If you prefer email us at Chef Paul Catering or use our Catering Request Form today.